2011 Prices Down, 2012 Hopes Up

by Real estate financingMission+
9 minutes read

Happy new year Redfinnians!

One more little gift under the tree for you! Just in time for the holidays, we released Redfin for iPad!

Like a magnificent medieval triptych, the app has a three-in-one interface — a map, a kaleidoscope of listing photos, a single house in all its glory — all in one screen. The app shot to the front page of Apple’s App Store from the day of its debut.

One other sugar-plum feature for Redfin fans: we now offer a monthly home report that shows you pictures and prices for all the homes that sold in the four or five blocks around your place. To sign up, just search Redfin for your home address, view the property’s details, then click the big sign-up link.

Hope and Darkness

The holiday spirit seems to have affected more than Redfin’s elf-engineers. Prices fell again, and yet analysts and investors are daft with the holiday spirit, convinced that real estate may finally be ready to recover. Why on the darkest day of the year, are we always so hopeful?

One can only conclude that hopefulness is in our nature, and thank goodness it is! Let’s consider all the reasons this coming year will be better than the last.

Prices Down 1.2%

But first, that lump of coal! The latest numbers show prices fell 1.2%:

Market MoM Change YoY Change Date of Max Change from Max Prices Last at
This Level
# of Months
of Decrease
Phoenix Real Estate 0.3% -5.1% Jun-06 -55.8% Feb-00 0
Los Angeles Real Estate -1.5% -4.9% Sep-06 -39.6% Sep-03 3
San Diego Real Estate -0.6% -4.5% Nov-05 -38.9% Oct-02 3
San Francisco Real Estate -0.7% -4.7% May-06 -39.4% Jan-01 3
Denver Real Estate -0.2% -0.9% Aug-06 -10.6% Jun-02 2
Washington DC Real Estate -0.3% 1.3% May-06 -25.4% May-04 1
Atlanta Real Estate -5.0% -11.7% Jul-07 -33.2% Aug-98 3
Chicago Real Estate -1.8% -4.8% Sep-06 -31.0% Aug-01 2
Boston Real Estate -1.1% -1.1% Sep-05 -16.3% May-03 3
Las Vegas Real Estate -1.5% -8.5% Aug-06 -60.7% Jul-97 4
New York City Real Estate -1.2% -2.0% Jun-06 -22.1% Mar-04 2
Portland Real Estate -0.5% -4.7% Jul-07 -27.4% Dec-04 1
Dallas Real Estate -0.9% -0.6% Jun-07 -8.7% May-04 2
Seattle Real Estate -1.0% -6.2% Jul-07 -30.2% Aug-04 3
20 City Index -1.2% -3.4% Jul-06 -32.1% May-03 2

Case-Shiller Home Price Index for October 2011, Not Seasonally Adjusted

Three months ago, we said that price gains were just a summer fling. Sure enough, once you adjust for seasonal swings, the index is now at a new post-bubble low.

But hey, it could be worse: last October, experts predicted a 5% – 10% drop but in fact prices over the past year dropped only 3% – 4%. As we’ve been saying all along, we’re at a rocky bottom with a downward trend. The West is stable:

Case Shiller Home Price Index - West

The East and Midwest, slightly less so, mostly because Atlanta fell off a cliff:

Case Shiller Home Price Index - East

Sure, Call It a Comeback If You Like

Now our favorite housing swami, the studly Bill McBride at Calculated Risk, has said that most of the price declines are over. All week, the most-emailed story in the Wall Street Journal has been about the hedge funds now buying up residential real estate:

Big money is starting to wager on housing. Hedge funds run by Caxton Associates LP, SAC Capital Advisors LP, Avenue Capital and Blackstone Group LP have been buying housing-related investments, betting on a rebound. And formerly bearish research firm Zelman & Associates now predicts a housing pickup, as does Goldman Sachs Group Inc.

We aren’t surprised: all year, Wall Street has bombarded our site with web robots trying to download data in bulk. But the Street has been wrong before. As one analyst cautioned: “The smartest money in the world has been carried out on stretchers betting on a true recovery for housing.”

You Want Good News? We’ve Got Plenty

What has convinced some investors that the housing market will be nice instead of naughty? All sorts of good news:

But don’t get cocky kid! Our own opinion is that home prices won’t fall or rise much in 2012. Prices can’t rise far before banks and regular home-owners put more properties on the market. And they can’t fall far because of increasing rents and — for now — declining foreclosures.

The Monster Under the Bed

The $24,000 question is: will foreclosures come back with a vengeance? Insiders warn that the backlog of foreclosed properties is “shockingly large,” a point no one disputes.

We worry about this, but less than others: the banks themselves don’t want to go back to 2008, when they ruined their own balance sheets by flooding the market with foreclosures at fire-sale prices. And many home-owners fretting about expiring teaser rates are discovering that the new rate is lower than the old one.

Rates Are Low, and May Stay That Way

So what I worry about is interest rates. How long can the whole economy hold together given the apocalyptic politics around U.S. budget deficits? Rates keep falling, now to 3.95%, and government lenders now expects rates to remain low at least through mid-2012.

Interest Rates Falling

Which brings us to our final prediction for 2012. If prices are low and relatively stable, and rates remain very low, sales will pick up. Just a guess. Or maybe a hope. Happy new year, and thanks for all your Redfin support!

Best, Glenn


Related Posts

Leave a Comment

* By using this form you agree with the storage and handling of your data by this website.

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Accept Read More

Privacy & Cookies Policy